Eli Makena Insurance Group

Protecting What
You've Built.
Securing What's Next.

Premium insurance solutions crafted for discerning individuals, business owners, and families who demand more than a policy — they demand a partner.

Scroll

Comprehensive Protection
for Every Dimension of Your Life

From your personal estate to your business empire, we provide tailored coverage through the nation's top-rated carriers.

Personal Lines

High-value home, luxury auto, umbrella, watercraft, fine art, jewelry, and specialty coverages designed for discerning individuals.

Learn More

Commercial Lines

Business property, general liability, professional liability, workers' compensation, and executive protection for growing enterprises.

Learn More

Life & Health

Whole life, term, universal life, disability income, and group health solutions to protect your family and key personnel.

Learn More

An Independent Agency
Working For You,
Not the Carrier.

As an independent brokerage, we are not tied to any single insurance company. That means we shop dozens of top-rated carriers to find the right coverage at the right price — and our loyalty is always to you.

  • 01
    Dedicated Account Management One point of contact who knows your portfolio inside and out.
  • 02
    Annual Coverage Reviews Your life evolves — your coverage should too.
  • 03
    Claims Advocacy We stand beside you through every claim, every step of the way.
  • 04
    Access to Elite Carriers Chubb, AIG, Pure, Markel, and more — the best in the industry.

Trusted by Those Who've
Built Something Worth Protecting

★★★★★

The team at Eli Makena truly understands the complexity of insuring a multi-property portfolio. Their attention to detail and white-glove service is unmatched.

James R. Real Estate Developer
★★★★★

After years of feeling like just a policy number elsewhere, working with this group felt like having a trusted advisor on our side. They saved us significantly on our commercial package.

Diane & Marcus L. Business Owners
★★★★★

When we had a significant claim, they fought for us every step of the way. That's when you truly find out what your insurance partner is worth. Exceptional.

Patricia O. Private Client

Ready to Elevate
Your Coverage?

Let's start with a complimentary consultation to review your current coverage and identify any gaps.

Built on Trust.
Driven by Purpose.

Eli Makena Insurance Group was founded with a clear purpose: to be a steadfast partner for individuals and businesses who refuse to compromise on protection.

More Than an Agency.
A Trusted Advisor.

Eli Makena Insurance Group was founded on a simple but powerful belief: that every client deserves truly personalized coverage from someone who understands their world. We built this firm to serve those with complex needs — executives, entrepreneurs, real estate investors, and families with significant assets.

As an independent brokerage, we have the freedom to access dozens of top-rated carriers nationwide. We do not push products — we build protection strategies. Every recommendation we make is guided by your unique situation, your goals, and your peace of mind.

We are proud to be a trusted partner not just at policy inception, but throughout every chapter of our clients' lives — through business growth, family milestones, and everything in between.

The Principles That Guide Everything We Do

Integrity

We give honest advice — even when it's not what you expect. Your trust is our most valued asset.

Excellence

We hold ourselves to the highest standard in every interaction, every policy, every claim.

Advocacy

When you need us most, we fight for you. Your interests always come before any carrier relationship.

Relationships

We invest in long-term partnerships, not transactions. Your success and security is our purpose.

Let's Start a
Conversation.

We'd love to learn about your world and show you what truly personalized insurance looks like.

Every Risk.
Covered Precisely.

We offer a full spectrum of insurance solutions — each one customized to match the complexity and value of what you've built.

Personal Lines

High-Value Homeowners

Comprehensive protection for primary residences, vacation homes, and luxury estates — including guaranteed replacement cost.

Luxury Auto

Agreed value coverage for exotic, classic, and collector vehicles through specialty carriers who understand their true worth.

Personal Umbrella

Excess liability protection that goes above your home and auto policies — up to $10M and beyond for true peace of mind.

Watercraft & Yacht

Marine coverage for sailboats, yachts, and personal watercraft, including agreed hull value and navigational limits.

Fine Art & Jewelry

Scheduled personal property coverage for art collections, jewelry, watches, wine cellars, and other high-value possessions.

Vacation & Rental Homes

Specialized coverage for secondary properties and investment rentals, including short-term rental endorsements.

Commercial Lines

Business Owners Policy

Bundled property and liability coverage for small to mid-size businesses — efficient, comprehensive, and cost-effective.

Commercial Property

Protection for buildings, equipment, inventory, and business income against fire, theft, weather, and more.

General Liability

Defense and indemnification for bodily injury, property damage, and personal injury claims against your business.

Professional Liability / E&O

Protection for professionals against claims of negligence, errors, and omissions in the services you provide.

Workers' Compensation

Statutory coverage for employee injuries, ensuring compliance while protecting your team and your bottom line.

Commercial Auto

Fleet and commercial vehicle coverage including liability, physical damage, and hired & non-owned auto protection.

Life & Health

Term Life Insurance

Affordable, high-value death benefit coverage for a defined period — ideal for income replacement and mortgage protection.

Whole & Universal Life

Permanent coverage with cash value accumulation — a cornerstone of sophisticated estate and wealth transfer planning.

Key Person Insurance

Business continuation coverage that protects your company against the loss of a critical owner or executive.

Disability Income

Income replacement coverage to protect your lifestyle and financial obligations if illness or injury sidelines you.

Group Health Benefits

Employer-sponsored medical, dental, and vision plans for small to mid-size businesses — attract and retain top talent.

Buy-Sell Agreements

Life insurance-funded agreements ensuring smooth business transitions in the event of a partner's death or disability.

Not Sure Where
to Start?

Our advisors will walk you through your exposures and recommend exactly what you need — nothing more, nothing less.

The Person Behind
Your Protection.

Brian K. Lister brings nearly two decades of experience across personal, commercial, and life insurance — dedicated entirely to your best interests.

BL

Brian K. Lister

President & Lead Agent

With nearly two decades of experience in the luxury automotive and insurance industries, Brian founded Eli Makena Insurance Group to deliver the kind of personal, expert guidance that discerning clients deserve. His background spans personal lines, commercial risk, and life insurance.

Your Coverage.
Precisely Priced.

Complete the form below and one of our advisors will reach out within one business day with a tailored coverage proposal.

A Consultation,
Not Just a Quote.

When you reach out, you're not entering an automated pipeline. A real advisor will review your needs, ask the right questions, and come back with a proposal that actually fits your life.

Response Within 1 Business Day Your time is valuable — we move quickly without cutting corners.
No Obligation Our consultations are complimentary. You're under no pressure to proceed.
Multiple Carrier Options We'll present you with options from top-rated carriers, not just one.
Full Transparency No hidden fees, no fine print surprises. Just honest, clear recommendations.

Request a Quote

All fields marked with * are required.

We're Here
When You Need Us.

Whether you have a question about your current policy or want to explore new coverage, our team is ready to help.

Contact Information

Phone 614.315.5088
Email brian@elimakenainsurance.com
Office Location PO Box 272
Scott Depot, WV 25560
Office Hours Monday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:30 PM
By Appointment on Weekends

Send Us a Message

We'll respond within one business day.

Knowledge That
Protects You.

Stay informed with expert insights on risk management, coverage strategies, and protecting what matters most.

I
Personal Lines
March 2025

Why High-Net-Worth Homeowners Need More Than Standard Coverage

Standard homeowners policies leave significant gaps for luxury properties. Here's what elite coverage actually looks like.

Read Article
II
Commercial
February 2025

5 Insurance Gaps That Can Sink a Growing Business

As your business scales, so does your exposure. We break down the five most common — and costly — coverage oversights.

Read Article
III
Life Insurance
January 2025

Whole Life vs. Term: What's Right for Your Wealth Strategy?

The choice between permanent and term life insurance has significant financial implications. Here's how to think it through.

Read Article
IV
Risk Management
December 2024

The Case for a Personal Umbrella Policy at Every Wealth Level

Umbrella liability coverage is the most underutilized — and most important — policy for discerning individuals.

Read Article
V
Business Owners
November 2024

Key Person Insurance: Protecting the Irreplaceable Heart of Your Business

If your business relies on one or two key individuals, this policy could be the difference between recovery and closure.

Read Article
VI
Planning
October 2024

Annual Insurance Reviews: Why the Best-Protected Clients Do This Every Year

Your life changes. Your coverage should too. We walk through what a thorough annual review should cover.

Read Article

Have a Question
About Your Coverage?

Our advisors are happy to answer any questions — no commitment required.